How Social Comparison Between Emerging and Established Research Institutions Informs Proposed Amendment to the Bayh-Dole Act

Researchers, policy makers, and university administrators continue to debate how the Bayh-Dole act shapes innovation, technology transfer, and the economic development potential of U.S. research institutions. A newly released SSRN preprint by scholar Clovia Hamilton adds a fresh and timely perspective to this conversation. The article, titled “How socially comparing emerging research institutions to established research institutions informs proposed amendments to the Bayh-Dole Act,” explores how differences in institutional status, resources, and social comparison dynamics influence the effectiveness of federal technology transfer policy. As a case study, the article focuses on a survey of 245 Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCU) STEM faculty and administrators.

A preprint of this article is now publicly available for download on SSRN, making it accessible to anyone interested in HBCUs. university inventions, patent licensing, university innovation policy, research commercialization, or the future of the Bayh-Dole.

Why does this research matter?

The Bayh-Dole Act has been one of the most influential pieces of U.S. innovation policy since 1980. It enabled universities to retain ownership of federally funded inventions, sparking the modern technology transfer ecosystem. However, not all institutions benefit equally.

Hamilton’s preprint examines:

  • how emerging research institutions compare themselves to long established research universities
  • how these comparisons potentially shape their ability to participate in technology transfer
  • structural disadvantages that may require policy adjustments
  • proposed amendments to Bayh-Dole that could level the playing field

This research analysis is especially relevant as policy makers revisit Bayh-Dole in light of equity, regional innovation, and national competitiveness concerns.

Key Themes Explored in the Article

This legal research offers a thoughtful and much needed analysis of how emerging research institutions like HBCUs navigate the technology transfer landscape shaped by the Bayh Dole Act. As policy makers consider updates to the law, this work provides valuable insight into how federal innovation policy can better support a diverse range of universities. There are five key themes explored in this law article.

1. Social Comparison Theory in Higher Education

This paper applies Leon Festinger’s social comparison theory to understand how emerging institutions evaluate themselves relative to established research universities.

2. Unequal Technology Transfer Capacity

Differences in funding, staffing and research infrastructure create persistent gaps in commercialization outcomes.

3. Policy Implications for Bayh-Dole

Hamilton proposes amendments aimed at improving equity in federal research commercialization, support for under-resourced institutions, and national innovation capacity.

4. The Future of University Technology Transfer

This research raises important questions about how the US can broaden participation in innovation ecosystems at HBCUs!

Download the SSRN preprint

The full preprint is available as a free download on SSRN

Surpassing Bostock: SEC Filing Deficits Mask LGBTQ Discrimination

Our journal article titled Surpassing Bostock: SEC Filing Deficits Mask LGBTQ Discrimination explores how current U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) disclosure requirements fall short in addressing workplace discrimination against LGBTQ individuals. Despite the landmark Supreme Court decision in Bostock v. Clayton County (2020), which affirmed that Title VII protects employees from discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity, the article argues that corporate transparency has not kept pace with legal protections.

Key Themes
  • SEC Disclosure Gaps: We highlight that while companies are required to disclose material risks and human capital metrics, they rarely report on LGBTQ-specific issues. This lack of visibility allows discriminatory practices to persist unchecked.
  • Materiality Blind Spots: Further, the lack of SEC reporting of LGBTQ discrimination complaints suggests that high tech company leaders perceive LGBTQ worker discrimination as immaterial to investors. This is the case despite growing evidence that inclusive workplaces correlate with better performance and reduced legal risk.
  • Corporate Evasion: Our article critiques how companies use vague language or omit LGBTQ data entirely in filings. This effectively masking discrimination and undermining accountability.
  • Policy Recommendations: To close these gaps, we propose enhanced SEC guidance, mandatory LGBTQ workforce data reporting, and stronger enforcement mechanisms.
Broader Implications

In addition, our research underscores the disconnect between legal progress and corporate accountability. It calls for a shift in how regulators and investors view LGBTQ inclusion. This is not just as a social issue, but a material factor in assessing corporate governance and risk.

Furthermore, this article is a compelling call to action for policymakers, investors, and advocates to push for more robust and inclusive disclosure standards that truly reflect the spirit of Bostock. It blends legal analysis with policy critique, urging systemic change to ensure LGBTQ protections are not just theoretical, but enforceable and visible. You can get the full text of our article here.

Dr. Clovia Hamilton

Tribute Celebration of Life – Benjamin Hamilton, Sr. – 1934 to 2025

My dad passed away in late June 2025. I wrote this tribute and celebration of life to my dad Benjamin Hamilton. This tribute was published in the Jackson Progress Argus newspaper:

Mr. Benjamin Hamilton was a retired U.S. postal service inspection clerk and retired U.S. Air Force officer. He served on Butt County’s Board of Equalization. He also taught raised beds classes as a master gardener. Ben was a handy-man, fine landscaper and carpenter. He built his home at 333 Stark Road and the house next to it for his best friend Leo Moylan (deceased). Ben’s family once sharecropped on the land and his dad, Frederick Douglas Hamilton, was an AME church pastor in Jackson.

Ben Hamilton was predeceased by his first wife Cassie Hamilton, his son Ben Jr., his second wife Edna Miller Hamilton, and siblings. He leaves behind three daughters Trina, Clovia and Kim; three grandchildren Brandon, Julian and Chloe; and great grandchildren.

Read more of my tribute to my dad Benjamin Hamilton and as a celebration of his life here:

Ben Hamilton tribute

Robocops to the Rescue

Many police departments are deploying police robots, sparking serious questions about their impact and oversight. Professor Scott Shackelford and I explored this topic in our research and posed the question: “Robocops to the Rescue?” The answer isn’t an enthusiastic yes. Instead, their use raises a range of concerns that demand careful scrutiny.

In fact, robocops often carry cameras designed for continuous monitoring, and some include facial recognition capabilities. These technologies create privacy challenges that require clear policies and public transparency.

The robots gather huge volumes of data—often referred to as “big data”—which can feed into predictive policing tools. But many worry that biased algorithms in these tools could deepen existing racial and socioeconomic inequalities. As data collection grows, cybersecurity also becomes a pressing issue. Authorities must establish strong safeguards, clarify who can access the data, how long they’ll store it, and offer citizens a way to request its deletion.

Robotic capabilities continue to evolve. Some robots now feature algorithms that analyze health indicators, emotional states, walking patterns, and voice patterns. These robocops no longer function as mere cameras—they’re becoming complex surveillance tools. Some can even be weaponized.

To address these risks, we wrote 25 recommendations for regulating robocops. Learn more and see our appendix filled with photos of robocops!

Clovia the Sweater Sommelier

Here is a little known secret:

Clovia is a Sweater Sommelier! Yes, I have a sweater fetish (smile).  I collect used sweaters. It started mostly in military surplus stores when I was in college. But, now I look for the really good stuff. I want cashmere and merino wool. I want designer labels. And I usually get these for five to ten bucks. I select only the finest fibers. In a world of fast fashion, I rescue the forgotten threads of elegance.

There were sweaters all over the house. They were in bins under beds, in bins in the closet, in bins on my floor in my bedroom. I bought an office lateral file cabinet. But that system and the bin system did not work for me because when I needed a particular color sweater, I had to hunt for it. So, I decided to build a double decker rack. This way I can see the sweaters.

I shop for Goodwill Glam!  I donated about 100 sweaters to charity. And if I bring a new used sweater home, I have to donate one.

Additionally, folks would ask me, “do you wear them all?” The answer is YES.  Here is my double decker vault.

As a matter of fact, I made it with pipes. I bought a kit for a pipe rack and then bought extra pipes to make the second tier. I call this my “sweater sanctuary.”  Thrift store shopping for bargains is a fun hobby!

Clovia Hamilton, the sweater sommelier!

Patented brand drug pricing reform

Introduction

Patented brand drug pricing needs reform. In their journal article titled “Patented Brand Drugs are Essential Facilities and Regulatory Compacts,” researchers Clovia Hamilton and Gerald Stokes address the need for more affordable patented drugs, an issue particularly highlighted during the COVID-19 pandemic. Brand drug companies argue that they must recover their research and development (R&D), marketing, and advertising expenses.

What about the incentive to innovate?

Need patented drug pricing reform

The incentive to innovate should also be preserved.

Here are the key points:

  1. Intellectual Property and Human Rights Clash:
    • Access to patented drugs raises tensions between intellectual property rights and human rights.
    • Drug companies deserve a profit and return on investment, similar to utility monopolies.
  2. Proposed Approaches:
    • Hamilton & Stokes proposes several solutions to this dilemma.
    • They conclude that patented drugs should be considered a public utility.
    • A model based on the public utility approach could set prices for essential drugs transparently, similar to electricity rates.

The COVID-19 health pandemic highlighted the need for more readily affordable patented drugs. Brand drug companies claim they must recover the costs of research and development (R&D), marketing, and advertising. They emphasize the importance of maintaining incentives for innovation. These companies assert their right to earn profits and secure returns on investment, similar to the guarantees provided to utility monopolies. Intellectual property rights often conflict with human rights when it comes to access to patented medications. We propose several strategies to address this conflict and argue that society should treat patented drugs as public utilities.

A public utility model offers a compelling framework for pricing essential drugs and treatments. However, drug companies and insurers should not determine prices through closed-door negotiations. The current system of pricing patented brand-name drugs requires reform. Stakeholders should negotiate prices publicly and transparently, just as they do with electricity rates. Investor-owned utilities demonstrate that essential services can remain profitable while benefiting consumers and delivering steady returns to investors. Drug manufacturers of essential medicines can achieve the same balance.

read more…

Money is Morphing – learn about cryptocurrency

In her article titled “Money is Morphing – Cryptocurrency Can Morph to Be a Sustainablemoney is morphing learn about cryptocurrency Alternative to Traditional Banking,” Clovia Hamilton explores the potential of cryptocurrency as an environmentally and financially sustainable alternative to traditional banking systems.

Money is morphing cryptocurrency research is a bibliometric study conducted using the critically appraised topic method using 201 publications between Jan 1, 2013, and Dec 31, 2022. The research focuses on the pros and cons of using cryptocurrency. This currency can provide improved access to banking and inclusion for many people in underdeveloped countries that lack banking services. Additionally, this study addresses how cryptocurrency can be a more sustainable alternative to traditional banking. traditional community financial institutions and how traditional currencies can morph by embracing digital financial technology. Financial institutions can remain relevant in the face of digital asset and cryptocurrency innovations. Ten recommendations for cryptocurrency policies and legal regulations were gleaned from this bibliometric study.

Professor Hamilton highlights the following key points:

  1. Cryptocurrency Benefits:
    • Money is morphing with the advance of cryptocurrency and digital currency can improve access to banking and financial inclusion, especially in underdeveloped countries lacking traditional banking services.
    • In addition, blockchain technology, which underpins cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin, enables decentralized, secure transactions on peer-to-peer networks.
  2. Energy Consumption Concerns:
    • Creating a single new bitcoin consumes as much electricity as a typical US household in 57 days.
    • Further, the annual energy consumption related to crypto mining is equivalent to that of Sweden (135 TWh).
  3. Recommendations for Sustainability:
    • Hamilton suggests that traditional community financial institutions and currencies can adapt by embracing digital financial technology.
    • Implementing the study’s recommendations can lead to more inclusive, community-oriented, and environmentally friendly use of cryptocurrency.

Read more and check out Clovia’s 10 recommendations…

See Clovia’s research presentation

Writing this summer? Please cite Clovia Hamilton’s research!

Cite Clovia Hamilton’s research (smile)!  Professor Clovia Hamilton loves research and I am very proud of this body of research developed over the course of more than 20 years! If you are writing this summer, please cite Clovia Hamilton’s research! black male researcher writing

Lay summaries

Writing This Summer? Cite Clovia Hamilton’s Research!

If you’re writing this summer—whether it’s a journal article, conference paper, blog post, or policy brief—please consider citing the work of Professor Clovia Hamilton. With over 20 years of scholarship spanning AI ethics, data privacy, intellectual property, and diversity in STEM, her research offers a rich foundation for scholars, practitioners, and policymakers alike.

Why Clovia Hamilton’s Work Matters

Professor Hamilton’s research is grounded in real-world challenges and offers actionable insights. Her scholarship addresses some of today’s most pressing issues, including:

  • The ethical deployment of AI and robotics in law enforcement
  • Sustainable cryptocurrency practices
  • Inclusive innovation and entrepreneurship
  • University technology transfer and commercialization
  • Intellectual property rights and antitrust policy

Her work is not only academically rigorous but also deeply committed to social justice, equity, and sustainability.

Highlights from Her Research Portfolio

One standout publication is her 2024 article in the DePaul Business & Commercial Law Journal, titled “Money is Morphing.” In it, Hamilton explores how cryptocurrency could evolve into an environmentally and financially sustainable alternative to traditional banking. She reviews 201 publications from 2013 to 2022 and offers ten policy recommendations for crypto companies, including signing the Crypto Climate Accord, using renewable energy, and supporting unbanked communities.

Transitioning from fintech to public safety, Hamilton’s 2023 co-authored paper on smart policing—presented at the American Society for Engineering Management Conference—examines the ethical and cybersecurity implications of deploying robocops. The study recommends transparency, robust data analysis capabilities, and the appointment of AI ethics czars to oversee implementation.

Bridging Technology and Social Equity

Hamilton’s work also shines in the realm of diversity and inclusion. Her 2020 article in the Applied Management Journal, “Increasing Diversity among Women Entrepreneurs in High Growth High Tech Using HBCU Female Academic Entrepreneurs,” outlines how Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs) can enhance tech transfer and entrepreneurship among women faculty. She proposes model IP policies and highlights the importance of resource allocation and institutional support.

In another compelling piece, “Black Americans Past and Present Created Frugal Innovations,” Hamilton challenges dominant narratives in innovation studies by documenting how Black Americans have long practiced frugal innovation and circular economy principles—often without recognition.

A Call to Action for Scholars and Writers

Whether you’re researching AI governance, sustainable finance, or inclusive innovation, Professor Hamilton’s work offers a wealth of knowledge. Her publications span peer-reviewed journals, conference proceedings, black female researcher writingand book chapters, making them accessible across disciplines.

As you write this summer, take a moment to explore and cite her research. Doing so not only strengthens your own work but also helps amplify the voices of scholars committed to equity, sustainability, and ethical innovation.

You can find her full list of publications at cloviahamilton.com

If you are writing this summer, please cite Dr. Clovia Hamilton’s research!

Summer 2024

Writing this winter break? Consider citing my research

Cite Dr. Clovia Hamilton’s research!  This article provides brief lay summaries of research findings in publications written by Professor Clovia Hamilton on these 6 topic areas:

  • Data Privacy
  • Diversity, equity, and inclusion in STEM academic entrepreneurship
  • Economic Development
  • High-tech leadership
  • Use of artificial intelligence and smart policing to reduce police misconduct
  • Technology transfer operations and management

professor writing winter breakPlease cite these in your research when you can. Also encourage graduate students and junior faculty to cite these when possible. Please send Clovia your lay summaries and she will do the same for you.

Short on time? Here is a pdf!

Data Privacy
  1. Developing a Measure of Social, Ethical, and Legal Content for Intelligent Cognitive Assistants

We reviewed the growth and associated legal issues of the of Voice Activated Personal Assistants (VAPAs) in private homes, banks, healthcare, and education. We then summarized the policy guidelines for the development of VAPAs. Then, we classified these into five major categories with associated traits. We developed a relative importance weight for each of the traits and categories; and suggest the establishment of a rating system related to the legal, ethical, functional, and social content policy guidelines established by these organizations. We suggest the establishment of an agency that will use the proposed consumer protection rating system to inform customers of the implications of adopting a particular VAPA in their sphere.

Hamilton, C., Swart, W., & Stokes, G. M. (2021). Developing a Measure of Social, Ethical, and Legal Content for Intelligent Cognitive Assistants. Journal of Strategic Innovation and Sustainability, 14 (3), 1-37.

  1. A Comparative Analysis of the EU GDPR to the USA’s data breach notifications

Here, we compared the European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) with the statutes of the 50 US states, highlight the challenges companies face and reveal the types of decisions companies must make to comply with these statutes. This brief comparative analysis highlights the challenges companies face in trying to comply with multiple regulations. The greatest challenge exists for the small business. Just knowing the regulations would be a challenge for the small business. The GDPR may remain consistent, but the statutes of the 50 US states continue to be amended. In addition, there are the statutes of other countries. More than 100 countries have enacted data protection legislation, and several other countries are in the process of passing such laws with data protection laws.

Garrison, C., & Hamilton, C. (2019). A comparative analysis of the EU GDPR to the US’s breach notifications. Information & Communications Technology Law28(1), 99-114.

 Diversity, equity and inclusion in STEM academic entrepreneurship and technology transfer
  1. Increasing Diversity among Women Entrepreneurs in High Growth High Tech Using HBCU Female Academic Entrepreneurs

There is a concentrated number of potential women entrepreneurs of diverse races among faculty in the United States’ Historically Black Colleges and Universities (known as HBCUs and are called ‘Black Colleges’ herein). This study describes the potential for developing university technology transfer in these Black Colleges as a strategy for increasing diversity among women entrepreneurs in high growth, high tech fields using female academic entrepreneurs. Using a novel theoretical framework, 24 Black Colleges with doctoral programs were compared to five (5) non-Black Colleges’ technology transfer programs. Additionally, the results of a correlation analysis support hypotheses regarding the relationships between tech transfer resource inputs and outputs. The results were used to develop a model intellectual property (IP) policy for Black Colleges. The Model IP policies can help these institutions improve their technology transfer and academic entrepreneurship endeavors. Ultimately, this will likely increase the diversity of women researchers, inventors and academic entrepreneurs in high growth, high tech fields.

Hamilton, C. (2020). Increasing Diversity among Women Entrepreneurs in High Growth High Tech Using HBCU Female Academic Entrepreneurs. Applied Management Journal21, 40-81.

  1. Using Ortho Arrays to Design Stated-Choice Surveys in emerging Research Institution’s Technology Commercialization and Academic Entrepreneurship (Summary)

In order to investigate the lack of tech transfer including start-up business formation at emerging research institutions (ERIs) such as Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs), it is proposed that the social comparison theory be used as the theoretical framework in a novel experimental design.  This study describes how orthogonal arrays can be used in the creation of a stated-choice survey of ERI administrators to assess the level and extent that these administrators compare their ERI employer to non-ERI majority schools with respect to technology commercialization and academic entrepreneurship.

Additionally, using Ortho Arrays to Design Stated-Choice Surveys in emerging Research Institution’s Technology Commercialization and Academic Entrepreneurship (Summary)In Program and Proceedings of the 26th Annual Conference of the International Association for Applied Management – London, England (Vol. 26, p. 24). Bowling Green, KY: International Association for Applied Management (IAAM), 2019.

  1. Black Americans Past and Present Created Frugal Innovations and Embraced Circular Economy Principles: The Marketing Dilemma

The concept of frugal innovation did not originate in Asia or India. The practice of the rich taking the poor’s innovations is not new. In particular, Black American slaves and freed slaves developed several inventions in poverty conditions. It is imperative that frugal innovation research be more historically accurate to reduce the marginalization of contributions developed by poor innovators and to increase the more widespread embrace of circular economy principles. If a poor innovator resides in a rich country, then that innovator should not be excluded from the frugal innovator category if frugality was indeed used to innovate.

Hamilton, C. (2018). Black Americans Past and Present Created Frugal Innovations and Embraced Circular Economy Principles: The Marketing Dilemma. In 11th Annual Conference of the EuroMed Academy of Business Research Advancements in National and Global Business Theory and Practice – Malta.

  1. Chinese Innovation and Global Integration – Theoretical Framework of Perceived Insecurities in University Technology Transfer

Given increased investments in university research and Chinese universities, it is important to be aware of conflicts between university technology transfer office staff and faculty within academic exchanges. University technology transfer is growing in China and is vital to China’s innovation and intellectual property program. This cultural difference has presented conflicts between American university researchers and Chinese national researchers in the United States. In addition, it has also resulted in race- based hate and discrimination directed toward Chinese students and faculty on university campuses. Conflicts between university technology transfer participants can thwart efforts to create thriving, successful university technology innovation and commercialization programs. This paper provides a literature review which defines insecurity as perceived threats felt by both the faculty researchers and TIO staff. From this literature review, a theoretical conceptual framework and hypotheses were developed to explain this phenomenon.

Hamilton, C. (2018). Chinese Innovation and Global Integration Theoretical Framework of Perceived Insecurities in University Technology Transfer. In 11th Annual Conference of the EuroMed Academy of Business Research Advancements in National and Global Business Theory and Practice – Malta.

  1. HBCU Technology Transfer Supply Chain Networks’ Sustainability: Budget Resource Planning Tool Development

This study describes the development of a university technology transfer supply chain network sustainability budgeting tool that Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs) can use to become more self-reliant financially. HBCUs lag behind their peer non-HBCUs because historically they have been under-served and were originally established largely as teaching and blue-collar trade schools. Increased involvement in research-oriented activities such as technology transfer will likely enable HBCUs to grow into new or stronger research institutions. The literature review revealed several problem areas with non-HBCUs university technology transfer including resource planning issues. These problem areas for non-HBCUs would be challenging for HBCUs as well.

Hamilton, C. (2018). HBCU Technology Transfer Supply Chain Networks Sustainability Budget Resource Planning Tool Development. In Proceedings of the American Society for Engineering Management 2017 International Annual Conference EH. Ng, B. Nepal, and E. Schott eds.

  1. A Tool Kit for Building HBCU Technology Transfer Supply Chain Networks Using an Advanced Planning System

This toolkit is an advanced planning system to help Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs) and other emerging research institutions (ERIs) engage in technology transfer and compete for licensing revenues. This study includes a historical account of why HBCUs are woefully behind predominantly White institutions in America with regard to R&D and technology transfer. It includes budget resource planning using linear programming, job scheduling using simulated annealing and R programming, benchmarking, and recognition of the need for a paradigm shift.

Hamilton, C. A (2016) A tool kit for building a HBCU technology transfer supply chain network. University of Tennessee.

Technology transfer operations and management
  1. Knowledge Based View of University Tech Transfer—A Systematic Literature Review and Meta-Analysis

What enables productive university technology transfer office (TTO) performance has not been comprehensively researched. Therefore, this research study adopted the knowledge-based view as the theoretical construct to support a comprehensive investigation into this area. This was achieved through employing a systematic literature review (SLR) combined with a robust meta-analysis. The SLR identified an initial total of 10,126 articles in the first step of the review process, with 44 studies included in the quantitative synthesis, and 29 quantitative empirical studies selected for the meta-analysis. The research study identified that the relationship between TTO knowledge management and knowledge deployment as well as startup business performance is where TTOs secure the strongest returns.

Hamilton, C., & Philbin, S. P. (2020). Knowledge Based View of University Tech Transfer—A Systematic Literature Review and Meta-Analysis. Administrative Sciences10(3), 62.

  1. A Cochrane method systematic review of university tech commercialization research

The technology transfer offices (TTOs) which were established at many research universities to manage this process have been studied quite extensively. However, the foundational elements that fuel successful TTO performance has not been studied comprehensively. Instead, there are numerous fragmented studies that date back to the early 1980s. In addition, there is no agreed upon common theory for studying university technology and how these elemental inputs related to performance outputs. Thus, herein it is advocated that the resource-based view (Barney, 1991) and theory on environmental munificence (Castrogiovanni, 1991, 2002) be used as a theoretical framework for researching university technology commercialization. Competitive resources in a more munificent environment can make it easier for an organization to survive and prosper. With a Cochrane method meta-analysis, it was discovered that human and organizational resources are significant relative to startup business formations, patents, and licensing activities. The strongest effects were among the organizational and human inputs relative to licensing activities.

Hamilton, C. (2018). A Cochrane method systematic review of university tech commercialization research. In Proceedings of the International Annual Conference of the American Society for Engineering Management. (pp. 1-11). American Society for Engineering Management (ASEM).

  1. A Meta-Analysis of University Technology Transfer Empirical Research (Summary)

Interestingly, this research helps university technology transfer offices (TTOs) identify key resource attributes that influence performance. Using resource-based theory, which emphasizes the value of rare and hard-to-imitate assets, the study explains how specific TTO characteristics relate to outcomes like patents, licensing, and startup formation. A comprehensive literature review included empirical studies that measured TTO resources (e.g., research budgets, staff, patents) and performance indicators (e.g., startups), along with effect size estimates. A meta-analysis revealed that both human and organizational resources significantly impact performance, especially in licensing. These findings suggest that TTOs with strong, unique, and well-managed resources achieve better results. The study underscores the importance of investing in experienced staff and robust organizational structures to enhance technology commercialization. By aligning with resource-based theory, the research provides a strategic framework for improving TTO effectiveness and maximizing the return on university innovation efforts.

Hamilton, C., & Crook, R. (2015). A meta-analysis of university technology transfer empirical research (summary). Frontiers of Entrepreneurship Research35(9), 4.

  1. University Technology Transfer from the Attention Based View

There is a persistent underperformance by university technology transfer offices. This paper makes the contribution of advocating the novel use of cognitive thinking’s attention-based view to university technology transfer in order to resolve this problem. The attention-based view teaches that human attention is limited and organizations are limited in what they pay attention to (Cyert, 1963; Ocasio, 1997). It is argued herein that universities may struggle with increasing their licensing revenues because they are not paying sufficient attention to licensing. Awareness of the problem is the first step in resolving it. It is propositioned that university technology transfer office staff pay more attention to intellectual property protection than patent marketing or licensing and this result in lower licensing revenues and lower overall performance. It is also propositioned that technology transfer offices with less experienced staff pay more attention to intellectual property protection than patent marketing and licensing.

Hamilton, C. (2015). University Technology Transfer Information Processing from the Attention Based View. In Proceedings of the International Annual Conference (IAC) of the American Society of Engineering Management (ASEM), Indianapolis IN (pp. 1-11).

  1. Love and Hate in University Technology Transfer

Problems with university technology transfer have led to unethical behavior among faculty inventors and university technology transfer specialists. This study examines the literature focused on the relationship between university research faculty and technology transfer office staff. We attempt to provide greater understanding of how research faculty’s personal values and research universities’ organization values may differ and why. Faculty researchers and tech transfer office (TTO) staff are perceived to be virtuous agents. When both are meeting each other’s needs, a “love” relationship exists. However, when these needs are not met, a “hate” relationship exists that is replete with doubt and uncertainty. This doubt and uncertainty create tension and subsequent conflicts. There are many accounts where faculty researchers have not followed university policies and expectations, often violating policy and ethical standards. Likewise, faculty report numerous examples of how TTO staff members’ negligence in servicing their attempts to be good institutional citizens have failed them.

Further, this paper explores this love/hate relationship and reveals numerous conflicts that call into question ethical concerns. It also provides a set of recommendations for reducing and potentially alleviating these concerns. Results from a thorough review of the literature on the relationship between faculty and university TTOs reveals that perceived job insecurity is the primary reason that some research faculty members as well as some TTO staff, unethically violate their university policy to disclose invention disclosures and select to not provide full services, respectively. One way to alleviate the conflict between faculty’s personal values regarding their inventions and university’s organizational values is to enact measures that build trust and reduce insecurity among faculty members and TTO staff. In this book chapter, we not only examine this faculty/TTO staff ethical conflicts, but we offer a set of recommendations that we believe will reduce the likelihood of unethical behavior while encouraging greater institutional commitment and trust.

Hamilton, C., & Schumann, D. (2016). Love and hate in university technology transfer: examining faculty and staff conflicts and ethical issues. In M. H. Schwartz, Howard (Ed.), The Contribution of Love and Hate to Organizational Ethics, Research in Ethical Issues in Organizations (REIO) (Vol. 16, 95-122): Emerald Group Publishing.

  1. Emerging Research Institutions’ Technology Transfer Supply Chain Networks’ Sustainability: Budget Resource Planning Tool Development

This study describes the development of a university technology transfer supply chain network sustainability tool that private and public emerging research institutions (ERIs) can use to become more self-reliant financially. Historically black colleges and universities (HBCUs) are ERIs and are used as a case study. HBCUs lag behind their peer non-HBCUs because historically they have been under-served and were originally established largely as teaching and blue-collar trade schools. Some doctoral HBCUs desire to strengthen their research activities. This study illustrates that classic industrial use of linear programming optimization techniques can uniquely be used to optimize budget resource planning for sustainable HBCU supply chain networks and other ERIs. Applying the systems dynamics approach, a budget resource planning tool was developed using a linear programming optimization technique. This study contributes to the improved execution of technology transfer projects through better budget resource planning.

Hamilton, C. (2017). Emerging research institutions’ technology transfer supply chain networks’ sustainability: Budget resource planning tool development. IEEE Engineering Management Review45(4), 39-52.

  1. Novel Job Scheduling Tool for University Technology Transfer

Technology commercialization managers are often faced with (1) training inventors on intellectual property (IP) laws and IP policies, (2) evaluating invention disclosures for patentability and marketability, (3) drafting and implementing invention marketing plans, and (4) working closely with patent counsel on patent prosecution. This study begins with the fact that expediency is important because the amount of time taken to evaluate invention disclosures and file patent applications often conflicts with inventors’ desire to publish their findings. However, very few technology transfer managers use project management job scheduling tools to minimize processing time. This study describes the development of a novel job scheduling tool for university technology transfer using simulated annealing in R programming.

Hamilton, C. (2020). Novel Job Scheduling Tool for University Technology Transfer. Applied Management Journal20, 19-37.

Antitrust Guidelines for Intellectual Property Licensing
  1. Adequacy of the 1995 Antitrust Guidelines for IP Licensing: Commentaries from the 2002 FTC and DOJ Hearings about the Competition and Intellectual Property Law and Policy in the Knowledge-Based Economy

The 1995 Antitrust Guidelines for the Licensing of Intellectual Property outline enforcement policies by the DOJ and FTC but fall short in offering clear guidance for practitioners. These guidelines misunderstand the complexities of IP markets and inadequately address key issues, particularly license misuse that creates market entry barriers. A flawed concept of the “innovation market” further weakens their effectiveness. This article examines whether the FTC has tackled three major forms of license misuse: (1) refusal to license IP, (2) misconduct during industry standards setting, and (3) improper acquisition of broad IP rights through patent settlements, including patent pools and cross-licensing. Further, special attention is given to generic drug market entry, which has drawn scrutiny due to its connection with online shadow markets and the controversial Medicare Bill. The article calls for clearer, more practical antitrust guidance to better navigate the evolving landscape of intellectual property licensing and enforcement.

Hamilton, C. (2004). Adequacy of the 1995 Antitrust Guidelines for IP Licensing: Commentaries from the 2002 FTC and DOJ Hearings. Journal of Internet Law, 7, 18-27.

  1. Adequacy of the 1995 Antitrust Guidelines for the Licensing of Intellectual Property in Complex High-Tech Markets

In 1995, the Department of Justice and the Federal Trade Commission adopted new guidelines for those wishing to license intellectual property rights without violating antitrust laws. Designed to provide clarity, these guidelines instead bred confusion because they misunderstand the nature of intellectual property markets and provide insufficient guidance in the most difficult areas. Agency guidance should focus on conduct in the high-tech arena that constitutes a potential entry barrier. Key high-tech entry barriers include refusals to license, misconduct during standards-setting activities, and patent accumulation methods such as cross licensing, package licensing, and patent pools. The article concludes that the government should further amend the Guidelines to provide clearer rules for use of IP licenses.

Hamilton, C. (2002). Adequacy of the 1995 Antitrust Guidelines for the Licensing of Intellectual Property in Complex High-Tech Markets. Computer L. Rev. & Tech. J.7, 23.

Note: The FTC and DOJ did amend the Antitrust Guidelines for IP Licensing in 2017.

High-tech ethical leadership

  1. Preparing Millennials as Digital Citizens and Socially and Environmentally Responsible Business Professionals in a Socially Irresponsible Climate

Current literature on using current events in business education lacks focus on helping millennials develop their individual voice and critically explore ethical, policy, and business issues. While some studies suggest students should select their own news stories, few address how educators can guide them beyond summarizing content. There is little emphasis on teaching diplomacy—an essential skill for navigating modern business careers. To bridge this gap, more research and practice are needed to create opportunities for students to express themselves in online discussions, form evidence-based judgments, and engage in meaningful debates on complex, often uncomfortable topics like unethical business practices. Encouraging these skills will better prepare millennials for professional communication challenges. A shift from passive consumption of news to active, reflective engagement is essential for cultivating thoughtful, articulate, and ethically aware business leaders.

Based on our literature review, we recommend a pedagogical framework for developing business management curricula which has the following ten (10) themes that need to be promoted and implemented by higher education administrative leaders and faculty:

  1. Socially responsive ethics – digital citizenship and environmental sustainability; social justice awareness using current events in teaching
  2. Self- Identity: In this age of selfies, faculty should encourage students to establish their own authentic self-identities.
  3. Diplomat Business Communication – encourage the development of experiential learning activities focused on civic participation for interventionist engagement
  4. Transparency the business schools need to begin at home with discussing digital citizen related decisions made by the university and their college related to cyber bullying, harassment, unethical behavior; and with related current events.
  5. Evidenced –based assignments: Evidence-based assignments will thwart any inclination for students to indulge in fake news and alt facts. Require Oral and Written Communication based on sound researched evidence.
  6. Assert their Rights and Opinions – in concert with discovering their self-identities, encourage students to learn what their rights and opinions are and exercise their voice

Burgess Wilkerson, B., Hamilton, C., Garrison, C., & Robbins, K. (2018). Preparing millennials as digital citizens and socially and environmentally responsible business professionals in a socially irresponsible climate. In Proceedings of the 83rd Annual Conference of the Association for Business Communication October 24-27, 2018 – Miami, Florida, USA.

  1. Q&A. Does Machiavelli’s The Prince have relevant lessons for Modern High-Tech Managers and Leaders?

High-tech business leaders’ character traits significantly influence their decisions and workplace behavior. Niccolò Machiavelli’s 16th-century treatise, The Prince, offers enduring lessons for navigating today’s competitive business environment. Machiavelli advises leaders to manage expectations, govern holistically—not just in crises—and act with strategic foresight, as if always preparing for battle. His emphasis on balance, consequence, and realism remains relevant, especially in industries where competition is fierce and leadership demands resilience. Understanding these principles equips modern leaders to handle ruthless challenges effectively. This article explores how Machiavelli’s insights apply to contemporary tech figures such as Steve Jobs, Meg Whitman, Larry Ellison, Steve Ballmer, Michael Pearson, Martin Shkreli, Marissa Mayer, and Martin Winterkorn.

Hamilton, C. (2017).Q&A. Does Machiavelli’s The Prince have relevant lessons for Modern High-Tech Managers and Leaders, Technology and Innovation Management Review, 7(8), 40-47.

Economic development
  1. Appropriation of Artisans’ Intellectual Property in fashion Design Accessories: Piracy Disguised as Giving Back?

Some companies in developed nations appropriate intellectual property from artisans in underdeveloped countries, later portraying themselves as altruistic by offering microloans. To avoid such exploitation, fashion accessory companies can adopt corporate social responsibility (CSR) practices that include hiring artisans directly, matching purchases with donations, forming nonprofits that return all proceeds to artisans, and using ethical manufacturing brokers. However, beyond voluntary CSR, countries should implement policies mandating royalty sharing or other equitable compensation for artisans. International bodies like WIPO can help facilitate these frameworks. While current CSR efforts are a positive start, true equity requires co-ownership models that recognize artisans as rightful intellectual property holders. Such models not only ensure fair compensation but also promote sustainable and ethical business practices that respect the cultural and creative contributions of marginalized communities. Protecting artisan IP through structural reforms is essential for long-term success and justice in global fashion markets.

Hamilton, C. (2020). Appropriation of Artisans’ Intellectual Property in Fashion Design Accessories: Piracy Disguised as Giving Back?. Intell. Prop. & Tech. LJ25, 127.

  1. Reimagining China’s transportation funding investments in Africa in the context of COVID-19

Africa’s underinvestment in healthcare, coupled with China’s growing role in financing its transportation infrastructure, has exposed vulnerabilities—especially during the COVID-19 pandemic. A literature review highlights the interdependence of key development sectors: healthcare, education, housing, environmental protection, safety, economic growth, and transportation. To build resilience, African nations must adopt a more integrated approach to development planning. Partnerships with China should go beyond transportation and include substantial investments in healthcare, education, utilities, and supply chain modernization using digital technologies. Trade agreements must be structured to support comprehensive development goals. Additionally, African governments should rethink domestic transportation spending to support broader social needs. For instance, U.S. models show how transportation funds can be used to build health clinics in transit hubs. Strengthening internal planning and aligning infrastructure investments with social services will help ensure that development is both equitable and sustainable.

Hamilton, C., & Maliphol, S. (2021). Reimagining China’s Transportation Funding Investments in Africa in the Context of COVID-19. Transportation Research Record.

Hamilton, C. (2021). Reimagining China’s transportation funding investments in Africa in lieu of COVID-19. Transportation Research Board 100th Annual Meeting Transportation Research Board, (TRBAM-21-01042).

  1. High-Tech Transportation Corridors are in Vogue: Proposed Federal Transportation Policy Amendments

The suburban space economy expanded in the 1980s, creating high-tech corridors along highways in Maryland, Virginia, and Washington D.C. By the early 2000s, high-tech transportation corridors (HTTCs) became a favored economic development strategy. Typically located along interstates or city streets, HTTCs cluster tech companies along key routes and are branded with corridor names (e.g., I-79 High-Tech Corridor). While some HTTCs form organically, many are actively promoted by economic leaders. To ensure these developments are equitable and sustainable, federal transportation policy should require planners to play a more engaged role in development decisions. These decisions must integrate infrastructure and resource programs with socio-economic goals. Planning should shift from a purely infrastructural focus to a more transactional, policy-driven approach. Transportation officials must evaluate the broader impacts of HTTCs before allocating funding, ensuring that these corridors support inclusive growth and long-term sustainability. A stronger link between transportation and socio-economic policy is essential.

Hamilton, C. (2003). High-Tech Transportation Corridors Are in Vogue: Proposed Federal Transportation Policy Amendments. Alb. LJ Sci. & Tech.14, 359.

  1. University Technology Transfer and Economic Development: Proposed Cooperative Economic Development Agreements under the Bayh-Dole Act

Although universities increasingly pressure their technology transfer specialists to become stewards of their regions’ economic development, most specialists have no experience in strategic economic development planning, or in forming collaborations that foster local government economic development. Furthermore, current regulations do not provide specialists with much guidance on how to facilitate economic development collaborations between their offices and other nonprofit organizations. This Article proposes that Congress amend the Bayh-Dole Act to provide guidance on how universities can enter into newly proposed Cooperative Economic Development Agreements (CEDAs) patterned after the Stevenson-Wydler Act’s Cooperative Research and Development Agreements (CRADAs).

Hamilton, C. (2003). University Technology Transfer and Economic Development: Proposed Cooperative Economic Development Agreements Under the Bayh-Dole Act, 36 J. Marshall L. Rev. 397 (2003).

  1. Identifying Sources of COVID19 Pandemic Supply Chain Fragility

This paper is a bibliometric study of the COVID19 supply chain fragility problem. In February 2021, the United States’ President called for a review of the pandemic related supply chain for vaccines, personal protective equipment (PPE), medical equipment such as ventilators, and food. This study involves a search for references published between January 1, 2020 and April 30, 2021. It reveals that food was a primary topic among 82 publications rather than vaccines. Also, reasons cited for America’s supply chain fragility include America’s dependence on products produced in other countries such as China; these countries’ own pandemic induced supply chain challenges; and US trade restrictions on such products enacted prior to the COVID19 outbreak. Engineering management strategies were mentioned in 60% of the publications and are summarized in the Conclusions and Implications for Managers are provided.

Hamilton, C. (2021). Identifying sources of COVID19 pandemic supply chain fragility. In Proceedings of the International Annual Conference of the American Society for Engineering Management. (pp. 1-11). American Society for Engineering Management (ASEM).

Smart policing
  1. Robocops and Smart Policing in the wake of the George Floyd murder

The killing of George Floyd in the United States has drawn attention to police brutality worldwide because it was caught on video. The frequency of incidents of police brutality has resulted in mutual distrust and fear between police and citizens. Repeated stories of police violence suggest policing needs a reimagined overhaul that addresses human rights. Smart technologies have the potential to improve policing and ethical outcomes through technological objectivity. Smart policing can potentially alleviate racial bias through technology management.

Maliphol, S. and Hamilton, C. (2022). Robocops and smart policing in the wake of the George Floyd murder. In Proceedings of Portland International Center for Management of Engineering and Technology (PICMET) Technology Management and Leadership in Digital Transformation, p. xx, August 2022, Portland, OR.

By Dr. Clovia Hamilton

 

 

I am frustrated with Google Scholar

I am frustrated with Google Scholar. We need citations to get tenure and promotion. It is hard enough to get published and to get those publications cited, then to have to deal with Google Scholar’s algorithms not counting the citations. What is more frustrating is when my cites are counted by Google Scholar and then disappear. I do not typically complain publicly about online apps. But, I am getting pretty weary of these issues.

Here is a list of my journal and conference publications that include self-cites to my past articles. Google Scholar is not counting these self-cites:

My research publications My self cites are not getting counted
Black American Slaves and Freed Slaves Created Frugal innovations and Creation of a Circular Economy, 2018 1.        Tool Kit for Building HBCU Technology Transfer Supply Chain Networks Using an Advanced Planning System, 2016

2.        Emerging Research institutions’ Technology Transfer Supply Chain Networks’ Sustainability: Budget Resource Planning Tool Development, 2017

3.        HBCU Technology Transfer Supply Chain Networks’ Sustainability: Budget Resource Planning Tool Development, 2017

Appropriation of Artisans’ Intellectual Property in fashion Design Accessories: Piracy Disguised as Giving Back?, 2021

 

4.        Emerging Research institutions’ Technology Transfer Supply Chain Networks’ Sustainability: Budget Resource Planning Tool Development, 2017

5.        HBCU Technology Transfer Supply Chain Networks’ Sustainability: Budget Resource Planning Tool Development, 2017

Knowledge Based View of University Tech Transfer—A Systematic Literature Review and Meta-Analysis, 2020 6.        High-Tech Transportation Corridors are in Vogue: Proposed Federal Transportation Policy Amendments, 2004

7.        University Technology Transfer and Economic Development: Proposed Cooperative Economic Development Agreements under the Bayh-Dole Act, 2003

A Cochrane method systematic review of university tech commercialization research, 2018 8.        High-Tech Transportation Corridors are in Vogue: Proposed Federal Transportation Policy Amendments, 2004

 

Novel Job Scheduling Tool for University Technology Transfer, 2020 9.        High-Tech Transportation Corridors are in Vogue: Proposed Federal Transportation Policy Amendments, 2004

 

 

Publications no longer counted

There are also 15 publications authored by other scholars where their citing my publications is no longer counted by Google Scholar. Frustratingly, I once got credit for these, but these cites disappeared in my Google Scholar profile:

Other scholars’ publications Citing the following paper that I authored

(but their cite is no longer counted by Google Scholar)

1.        Malik (2020), Patent rights and competition law: Conflicts and need for harmonization Adequacy of the 1995 Antitrust Guidelines for IP Licensing:  Commentaries from the 2002 FTC and DOJ Hearings about the Competition and Intellectual Property Law and Policy in the Knowledge-Based Economy, 2004
2.        Rutgers University (2003), Thirty-Fifth Selected Bibliography on Computers, Technology, and the Law (January 2002 Through December 2002) Adequacy of the 1995 Antitrust Guidelines for the Licensing of Intellectual Property in Complex High-Tech Markets, 2002
3.        McKernan (2005), Intellectual Property v. Antitrust Law an Examination of Department of Justice and the Federal Trade Commission’s Guidelines Concerning Licensing Intellectual Property Adequacy of the 1995 Antitrust Guidelines for the Licensing of Intellectual Property in Complex High-Tech Markets, 2002
4.        Sinaga (2019), Involvement of Grower, Supplier and Product innovation in Determining the Business Performance of Malaysian Poultry industry: Moderating Role of Management Skills HBCU Technology Transfer Supply Chain Networks’ Sustainability: Budget Resource Planning Tool Development, 2017
5.        Bozeman (2013), Technology Transfer Research and Evaluation: Implications for Federal Laboratory Practice

 

University Technology Transfer and Economic Development: Proposed Cooperative Economic Development Agreements under the Bayh-Dole Act, 2003
6.        Stephen (2010), Asian initiatives on Bayh-Dole with Special Reference to India

 

University Technology Transfer and Economic Development: Proposed Cooperative Economic Development Agreements under the Bayh-Dole Act, 2003
7.        Kay (2010), Extending Tort Liability to Creators of Fake Profiles on Social Networking Websites

 

University Technology Transfer and Economic Development: Proposed Cooperative Economic Development Agreements under the Bayh-Dole Act, 2003
8.        Nair (2009), Protection and Use of Publicly Funded Intellectual Property

 

University Technology Transfer and Economic Development: Proposed Cooperative Economic Development Agreements under the Bayh-Dole Act, 2003
9.        National Academies Press (2007), Rising Above Gathering Storm Energizing and Employing America for A Brighter Economic Future University Technology Transfer and Economic Development: Proposed Cooperative Economic Development Agreements under the Bayh-Dole Act, 2003
10.     US Congress, US House of Representatives Committee on Science & Technology (2005), Science, Technology and Global Economic Competitiveness: Hearing Before the Committee on Science, House of Reps 109th Congress University Technology Transfer and Economic Development: Proposed Cooperative Economic Development Agreements under the Bayh-Dole Act, 2003
11.     Hyndman (2005), Technology Transfer What India Can Learn

 

University Technology Transfer and Economic Development: Proposed Cooperative Economic Development Agreements under the Bayh-Dole Act, 2003
12.     Bloomberg (2004), Federal funded inventions and Bayh Dole Act compliance

 

University Technology Transfer and Economic Development: Proposed Cooperative Economic Development Agreements under the Bayh-Dole Act, 2003
13.     Furniss (2004), Amici Curiae University of Rochester, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. G.D. Searle & Co., inc., Monsanto Company, Pharmacia Corporation, and Pfizer inc., Defendants-Appellees, 358 F.3d 916 (Fed. Cir. 2004) University Technology Transfer and Economic Development: Proposed Cooperative Economic Development Agreements under the Bayh-Dole Act, 2003
14.     Duh (2017), Patent ownership of R&D funded by the government focusing on the university teacher relationship

 

University Technology Transfer and Economic Development: Proposed Cooperative Economic Development Agreements under the Bayh-Dole Act, 2003
15.     Schmidt (2019), Socially Responsible Learning in the Digital Age: A Literature Review

 

Preparing Millennials as Digital Citizens and Socially and Environmentally Responsible Business Professionals in a Socially Irresponsible Climate, 2018

And there is more! Librarians helped me find more citations. Many scholars in China and other countries have cited my publications over the years and Google Scholar are not citing these:

My research publications Others citing my research
A comparative analysis of the EU GDPR to the US’s breach notifications, 2019 Selle (2020), The Data breach Notification Obligation in the GDPR: Assessing the interpretative and Practical Problems posed by the Obligation, Master’s Thesis, University of Oslo
Adequacy of the 1995 Antitrust Guidelines for the Licensing of Intellectual Property in Complex High-Tech Markets, 2002 Chang, Aileen

Chapter 2 mobile phone product structure

 

Adequacy of the 1995 Antitrust Guidelines for the Licensing of Intellectual Property in Complex High-Tech Markets, 2002 Chang, Aileen (2006)

Strategic IP structuring in M&A of mobile phone businesses utilizing the BenQ Siemens merger for a case study

Adequacy of the 1995 Antitrust Guidelines for the Licensing of Intellectual Property in Complex High-Tech Markets, 2002 Chen, Andy (2004)

The Current and Future Regulation of Predatory Conduct – An Evaluation Under the New Economy System

Adequacy of the 1995 Antitrust Guidelines for the Licensing of Intellectual Property in Complex High-Tech Markets, 2002 Gözlükaya, Fatma (2005)

Teknoloji Transferi Sözleşmeleri Ve İlgili Rekabet İncelemesinin Ekonomik Ve Hukuki Unsurlari (Technology Transfer Agreements Turkish Competition Authority)

Gozlukaya 2005 technology transfer agreements Turkish competition authority

Master’s Thesis

Adequacy of the 1995 Antitrust Guidelines for the Licensing of Intellectual Property in Complex High-Tech Markets, 2002 McKernan, Francis (2005)

Intellectual Property v. Antitrust Law an Examination of Department of Justice and the Federal Trade Commission’s Guidelines Concerning Licensing Intellectual Property

Adequacy of the 1995 Antitrust Guidelines for the Licensing of Intellectual Property in Complex High-Tech Markets, 2002 Zhimin, Chen

Under the new economic system, the relationship between the exercise of Intellectual property rights and non-price predation behaviors and analysis of the necessity of antitrust law

Adequacy of the 1995 Antitrust Guidelines for the Licensing of Intellectual Property in Complex High-Tech Markets, 2002 Luo Jing (2008)

Legislation Regulation of Antimonopoly law on intellectual property license

Hunan University Thesis

Adequacy of the 1995 Antitrust Guidelines for the Licensing of Intellectual Property in Complex High-Tech Markets, 2002 Yi, Wang (2008)

On the Coordination of Intellectual Property Law and Competition Policy – The reference significance of European and American experience for our country

Master’s Thesis

High-Tech Transportation Corridors Are in  Vogue: Proposed Federal Transportation Policy Amendments, 2004 Kang, Heon (2007)

The Study on Patent Protection of Nanotechnology

나노기술의 특허보호에 관한 연구
Preparing Millennials as Digital Citizens and Socially and Environmentally Responsible Business Professionals in a Socially Irresponsible Climate, 2018 Ikechukwu, Eleba Victor

Eke, Pau (2019)

Perceived challenges of Millennial generations in on-line community development engagements in Imo state

University Technology Transfer and Economic Development: Proposed Cooperative Economic Development Agreements Under the Bayh-Dole Act, 2003 Ping, Wang Tai (2009)

On the Public Policy of Intellectual Property

Ping Wang Tai on the public policy of Intellectual property

University Technology Transfer and Economic Development: Proposed Cooperative Economic Development Agreements Under the Bayh-Dole Act, 2003 Wu, Chen (2009)

The Evaluation and Prospect of legal system construction on industry university research institution cooperation in China

In Chinese

Thesis Management School Huazong University of Science & Technology in Wuhan

University Technology Transfer and Economic Development: Proposed Cooperative Economic Development Agreements Under the Bayh-Dole Act, 2003 Wang Shujun (2015)

Study university patents public interest perspectives

Thesis

 

Being frustrated with Google Scholar is energy consuming. Google Scholar shows that I have only 70 cites. I should have at least 94 when these errors are corrected. I count even more because there are cites to urban planning studies that I have worked on which Google Scholar has not counted.

bar chart of annual citations to Clovia Hamilton's publications

Clovia Hamilton Google Scholar profile

Here is more frustration

I contacted Google Scholar a long time ago and they sent an email stating that this problem is due to broken links somewhere. I contacted repositories of my publications and was told that there are no broken links. You can read countless posts in Quora, Stack Exchange, Academia and ResearchGate about these issues. Interestingly, it is not just a problem I am facing. This has been a pervasive problem for many years. We can point these errors out and Google Scholar’s staff does not seem willing to go into their system and manually make corrections. In my opinion, if their algorithm does not pick this up, then tough.

What Google Scholar needs to do!

I think Google Scholar needs to do much more for scholars to ensure that our counts are correct. The founding vision for Google was to create a library of sorts. Scholars are key to any library of publications. Academics deserve more care and attention from Google.

Scholars are not just frustrated with Google Scholar. This dilemma is closely related to recent complaints about Facebook. The concern is over Facebook allegedly putting profit over people. Well, there are several authors who have stated that Google Scholar is a low priority for Google because it is not revenue generating. Further, there are no paid for ads on the site. So, Google’s staff does not put as much energy into the site. I experienced this because I would either get no reply or I would get the message that there are broken links somewhere that are out of Google’s control. Google can do better.

#Google_frustrates_scholars

By Dr. Clovia Hamilton

Assistant Professor

Department of Technology and Society

SUNY Korea